NewsIn Focus

Actions

Adnan Syed files for relief under the Juvenile Restoration Act

Posted
Adnan Syed, Shamim Rahman

Yet another step in the court case of Adnan Syed, a man whose conviction for killing his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee in 1999, currently stands pending a re-do hearing.

Syed's lawyer, Erica Suter, has filed a motion to reduce his sentence under the Juvenile Restoration Act.

The law, passed by the Maryland General Assembly in 2021, offers relief to people incarcerated for crimes they were convicted of committing when they were under 18, and have already served 20 years.

MORE ON THE JRA: Advocates oppose release of murderer convicted in 1982 case

Syed's legal team previously filed under this law a couple of years ago, which led to a Brady investigation by the State's Attorney's Office and a vacatur hearing in the fall of 2022.

The State's Attorney's Office filed the motion to vacate Syed's conviction citing new evidence and possible Brady violations.

A judge released Syed the same day, vacating his conviction.

IN FOCUS: Timeline: Adnan Syed's 23-year journey to freedom

Lee's brother, Young Lee was only notified on a Friday about the Monday hearing, and this led to additional court proceedings all the way up to the State Supreme Court which found Young Lee's rights had been violated.

The conviction, which had been reinstated by the Maryland Appellate Court, remains in place until a new vacatur proceeding could take place following the ruling of the State Supreme Court.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE: New filings from State, Lee in Syed Supreme Court Case

That proceeding has not yet been scheduled.

In the meantime, his lawyer has filed for a sentence reduction.

"This filing is a small step toward ensuring that Adnan's custody status is stabilized and his freedom is safeguarded," says Suter.

WATCH IN FOCUS COVERAGE:

The Hae Min Lee Files

"We maintain his innocence and our mission of proving that hasn't changed," she added. "At this time our concerns are focused on Adnan's liberty."

In a statement, the lawyer for Hae Min Lee's family said they plan to present the family's position in this matter in the days ahead.

"The family of Hae Min Lee has always said that if there is new and compelling evidence to support vacating the conviction of Adnan Syed, we will be the first to call for Mr. Syed's freedom," says David Sanford, the Lee family's lawyer. "To date, Mr. Syed and the State of Maryland have not presented a shred of new, let alone compelling, evidence that would warrant overturning a murder conviction that has withstood appeals for over two decades."

In filing for relief under the Juvenile Restoration Act, his lawyers aren't asking for his conviction to be overturned, but arguing that since his release from prison in 2022, he's been a law-abiding citizen and should therefore be granted relief under the law.

Sanford goes further in his statement.

"The State of Maryland engaged in a charade in 2022: it recycled old evidence and, in the process, bamboozled the trial court and the public into believing that Mr. Syed was likely innocent," he says. "Adnan Syed remains a convicted murderer. Having failed to produce new evidence and without any acknowledgment of guilt by Mr. Syed, Syed's attorneys now seek mercy, arguing that Mr. Syed is not a danger to the public."