BALTIMORE — With companies dropping Ye, the entertainer formerly known as Kanye West, following a series of antisemitic comments, many have taken to Twitter to express frustration that companies hadn't cut ties with him sooner.
Former Ravens player, Torrey Smith, tweeted this on Wednesday and received pushback for what many saw as an antisemitic trope.
Kanye never got canceled for saying all of the wild things he said about black folks because there aren’t many black people in powerful positions. He literally offended a group of people that do have power and influence in every space.
— Torrey Smith (@TorreySmithWR) October 26, 2022
It’s not rocket science. Don’t be stupid.
The idea that 'Jews have too much power' is considered an anti semitic trope by the Anti-Defamation league and other organizations that work to fight antisemitism.
Smith, later tweeted that, he learned about this during the day and attempted to clarify the original intention of his tweet.
I’m done though. This isn’t an debate that can’t be won. I’ve learned that Jewish folks in power is a antisemitic trope but I was literal going off of the actually boards and leaders. Wasn’t my intentions. I went by what I actually saw.
— Torrey Smith (@TorreySmithWR) October 26, 2022
Respect and Love ALL people!
Smith also spoke with WMAR-2 News on the phone on Wednesday afternoon, to further clarify what he was trying to say.
"My intentions were to talk about how nothing happened to Kanye when he was saying anti-Black things or really about anyone," said Smith. "Because you have no one in that space... Balenciaga, Gap, adidas, none of those companies have - maybe one of them has - a single Black person on their boards."
"When it come to the attacks that were made from him, he said plenty of things that I felt warranted him to lose his position and partnerships with these companies when he was talking about Black people, but again, there was no representation on the board."
He went on to say that he was talking about the actual boards of those three specific companies and how they have Jewish people on those boards.
Gap, Inc. was co-founded by a Jewish couple Doris and Donald Fisher in the 1960's. Doris Fisher is an honorary lifetime board member and two of her sons are currently on the Board of Directors.
It was not immediately clear if any of the people on the 6-member adidas Executive Board or the 13-member Kering Board of Directors (the parent company of Balenciaga) were Jewish, though one of the independent directors at Kering does have a commonly Jewish last name.
We also spoke with Howard Libit, the Executive Director of the Baltimore Jewish Council, about the series of tweets.
Libit said the most important thing is to educate people about anti semitism.
"I'm reading through those tweets today. It looks like, you know, some people reached out they got to him," he said. "He's been educated, he's expressed contrition and expressed, 'I learned something today.' Well, that's really what we want."
While Smith agreed that he has learned something after talking and engaging with several people, he doesn't feel he needs to take any additional time to research this area.
"I stand firmly by what I meant by people in leadership positions are primarily Jewish and white, so therefore, their reaction to it is different than had it been— And that's not to say that these groups only move when something impacts them. That's not what I'm saying. But it moves a lot quicker," he said.
A follow up from earlier pic.twitter.com/aQBFfzwKAs
— Torrey Smith (@TorreySmithWR) October 27, 2022
And on Thursday morning, Baltimore City Councilman Yitzy Schleifer, who is Jewish, posted on Twitter calling Smith's comments "offensive and dangerous."
@TorreySmithWR your comments about Jews is offensive and dangerous. Additionally, your statement about the @adidas board and others is simply not true. I would like to believe you when you say you didn’t intend on coming across in an antisemetic manner, but why triple down
— Isaac Yitzy Schleifer (@CouncilmanYitzy) October 27, 2022
My entire point was about representation and I expressed that. In other tweets. There are Jewish people in multiple levels of Adidas. Your statement is false. Either way, my thoughts and intentions were not intended to hurt anyone and was only about representation and change.
— Torrey Smith (@TorreySmithWR) October 27, 2022
Clearly you’re not getting it. If you actually care, I would be happy to sit down and explain why your statements are so offensive and dangerous. You have more followers on social media than there are Jews in the State of Maryland. You statements fuel the flames of antisemitism.
— Isaac Yitzy Schleifer (@CouncilmanYitzy) October 27, 2022
I’ve talked to multiple friends yesterday about this. I made a video making my point. I understand she issues are hand. If you want to talk just to talk that’s fine but I’m comfortable with what I said and what I’ve learned.
— Torrey Smith (@TorreySmithWR) October 27, 2022
On Thursday afternoon, Smith released an apology on Twitter.
After talking to some of my friends and members of the Jewish community, I would like to apologize for the hurt that some people have experienced from my tweet. That was not my goal and I understand why people feel that way. I was speaking strictly about representation but
— Torrey Smith (@TorreySmithWR) October 27, 2022
Recognize that my point falls in line with an antisemitic trope. I know what that means for the Jewish community during this time. The thought of being a person that could influence someone to harm someone else is crazy. That’s not how I live or believe anyone should be treated.
— Torrey Smith (@TorreySmithWR) October 27, 2022